"What's a sexual fantasy or fetish that you've never shared with anyone else?" Gia asked asked Ty as they lay in bed one night. "I want to try to make it come true."
"Never told anyone? I'm not sure I have one. We've done pretty much everything I've ever wanted." They certainly had been sexually active in their 6 years together.
"Oh come on, that's no fun. There has to be other stuff you want to do. Or anything that can't be done."
"How about you go first?"
"No no, you're not getting out of this that easily."
"Fine." Ty thought for a few minutes. "Well, there is one..."
Gia perked back up, having thought he was just going to pretend like he'd fallen asleep. "And what's that?"
"Well, look, it sounds a little weird at first, but-"
"I don't need an intro. Just spill"
"Fine. You know, like, Freaky Friday?"
"Yeah, what about it?"
"And body swap stuff in media generally."
"Uh huhhh. It's a fun trope."
"Well, I don't know. I think that's kind of hot. To live as somebody else for a bit, act like them in their lives. Specifically to even be a girl, experience it all from the other side. Maybe even a sexy white girl like you, enoy all your curves for my self."
"Really? You'd be down for that? Like pegging?"
"No, not like pegging, because it wouldn't be me as a guy. I'd actually be the girl, and my body would be built for that, made for that, you know?"
"Oh really?" Gia sat up, fake offended. "You think the female body is made for that? For penetration? Made for sex?"
"Well yours sure is," Ty said with a smile.
Gia smiled. "Well that was smooth." She kissed him deeply. "I'm not sure how to make it come true, though."
"I know. It's just one of those things. There's roleplay, I guess, but that isn't quite the same. There's a site I visit that has stories and captions about that stuff." He showed her a few TG caption websites. "And that's enough for me, I guess."
"Interesting," Gia said as she thought on Ty's newly disclosed fetish. "It would be fun to see things from the other side, I guess."
Ty thought she muttered something about roleplay, but she just shrugged and snuggled into him. They held each other close, each wrapped in their own thoughts, as they faded off to sleep.
[ * * * ]
Ty woke up groggy the next day. He'd tossed and turned, or maybe Gia had. And had she been on her phone for a while? He couldn't quite be sure what was real.
Their conversation from the night before came back to him slowly. Had he really confessed that to her? He'd never told anyone about his interest in TG stuff. Sure, a few guys would sometimes bring it up as a fun hypothetical, but that was something different. He stretched his neck, then slowly sent a hand to investigate his body. Sometimes in the captions people wake up switched without even realizing it.
It had been a vain hope. He found his usual, day-to-day male body beneath his shoulders. He turned to Gia, who remained dozing, and kissed her shoulder.
"Morning," he said.
"Morning," she responded. She cleared her throat, then said again "morning." She cleared her throat again, then "morning" a third time. "I can't seem to get this frog out of my throat."
"Frog? You sound normal to me," Ty said.
"Who the-?" Gia turned around at the sound of his voice and stared at him with wide eyes.
"What's wrong?" Ty asked.
"Gia? Is that you in there?"
"What?"
She brought a hand up to her face, then ran it through her long hair before settling them on her breasts, squeezing them slightly and rhythmically. A small moan escaped her lips. "Oh wow."
"Gia? What's up with you?"
"Gia?" Shea smiled at him. "Oh, you want to play it like that? Sure, I'm Gia then. And you're still Ty."
"Right...'
Gia brought her hands to his face and kissed him deeply. "I think you're a little slow today, baby. But I need you to catch up, because I want you to show me how this body feels."
This body, thought Ty. He slowly started piecing it together. "Wait, so you're roleplaying like you're T-"
Gia put her finger on his lips. "Not roleplaying. I am. I'm actually Ty. And maybe you're a copy of me, or me of you, or maybe you're Gia in there really good at playing dumb." Maybe she was a better actress than Ty thought. Or maybe...
"But that's neither here nor there," 'Gia' continued, "because just sitting here in this body and thinking of what is to come is getting me all hot and bothered." She grabbed Ty's hand and led it to her crotch. He could feel her warmth and wetness through her panties, and she moaned loudly at just the touch. Louder, maybe, than she'd ever moaned before, and that was before he slipped a finger inside.
"Oh fuck!" she screamed. "So that's what that feels like. Holy fuck!" Ty pulled his finger slowly back and forth, warming Gia up as she moaned louder and louder. He brought a thumb up to her clittoris and watched her eyes roll into the back of her head. She grabbed a pillow to scream into, and he continued fingering her for several minutes. Eventually, shaking, she grabbed his hand and pulled it away from her womanhood.
"Oh my god. How are you not doing that all the time?" She asked Ty as she sat up. He didn't answer, he just kissed her deeply and pushed her back down onto the bed before mounting her.
"I'm so much smaller now," she said. "You can really just toss me around now."
Ty grunted and pulled her panties off roughly before bringing her shirt up over her head. She saw his penis straining at his boxers and hesitantly brought a hand up to it.
"It's so big from this angle."
Ty pulled down his boxers and his fully erect penis flopped out, nearly at her face. She went wide-eyed and pulled back. Maybe she was a really good actress after all, reacting to a penis she'd seen a hundred times like that. Or maybe, Ty thought, just maybe, it was actually somehow a copy of him in there. He was jealous of the copy, if it was actually one. But at the same time, the situation, roleplay or real, had him nearly bursting at the seams.
He lined up his penis against Gia's pussy lips, lubbing the head of his cock up at the mouth of her pussy. She moaned at the slightest touch, just as Ty imagined he would. He pulled back, ready to take the plunge, when she held a hand up.
"Wait... wait," she said
Ty stopped, holding his throbbing penis. He wasn't even sure how long he could last like this.
"I don't think I can take it this way yet. Not looking at my old face"- That had been a thought that Ty had had about the hypothetical as well, one he'd seen in a few captions- "so I want you to take me from behind. I want you to do me doggy."
"Only if we can do it in front of the mirror. So you can see how you look taking a cock."
Gia looked shocked for a split second, then smiled. "Yes. Absolutely." Gia took her position on all fours in front of the mirror somewhat more clumsily than she normally did. "Like this?" she asked with her ass in the air.
Ty didn't respond. He couldn't wait to fuck Gia, or himself, or whoever was in her body any longer. He just lined himself up and inserted himself into her pussy.
"Funggggggggggg," Gia said. Or tried to say. Her words quickly devolved into moans and panting as Ty pounded her from behind, pulling her hair the way she liked. Doggy style was the best way to admire her curves, Ty had decided long ago, and to admire the way she shifted and jiggled when getting pounded. He wondered what it felt like.
She looked at herself in the mirror, only sparing a few glances up at Ty, before looking back to herself and the way her whole body shook as she got fucked from behind, her breasts swaying wonderfully beneath, absolutely at Ty's mercy.
Ty's cock swelled as he neared completion.
"Oh god!" Gia shouted, evidently feeling what was about to happen. "Please! Don't! Cum! Insi-! me!" She could barely get a word out between thrusts.
Ty didn't heed her request. He knew she always preferred creampies and knew she liked to roleplay like she didn't. She was on birth control, she wouldn't get pregnant as long as she remembered to take it.
"Don't! Get! Me! Preg-! Nant! As! You!"
He blew his load inside of her, having the best orgasm he'd had in months as she continued moaning and pleading. He slowed his thrusts down, making sure everything was out before sliding slowly out of her. She turned over, panting heavily, a satisfied look on her face as cum dripped out of her pussy.
"Well," he asked, "how was that?"
"As far as first times go, it was incredible." She put a finger down to her pussy and pulled up some cum. She looked at it for a second before making eye contact with Ty and putting it in her mouth.
That was a new move, Ty thought. He'd never seen her do that before. Could it really be a copy of Ty inside of Gia? She only smiled at him cryptically.
He couldn't be quite sure who was in Gia's body.
But he knew he'd keep railing her like that regardless.