I had just gotten my Halloween costume from the shop. It wasn't the one I wanted. It never was. I was going to a rager Halloween party with my buddies from college and they wanted to do a group mario party costume. But that wasn't why I was unhappy with my costume.
Every year I told myself that I was going to express that deep part of me through a Halloween costume "as a joke." I would put in all of the effort I could and make myself passable as a woman. I was short already at 5'9" and thin. I figured with a little makeup and prosthetics I could pass pretty convincingly. I always wanted to know what that was like but I was too scared. My friends would mock me relentlessly, joke or not.
So when they decided it was a Mario themed group costume this year I ended up with freaking Luigi as my costume. I thought about getting a peach costume but chickened out. Looking at the green hat and blue overalls in my bag I sighed.
Thats when I thought about how weird the chick in the shop had been while I was looking. "Oh I know you don't want these types of costumes right?" She had asked. "Are you sure? Wouldn't you rather look at some other ones?" her eyes had darted to the female section. If that wasn't weird the next part was. While I was picking out a costume she disapeared. When I was ready to buy the costume I rang the bell "Just a minute!" she yelled. I had to wait 5 minutes before she came back. I almost left because there was this weird smell coming from the back room. She must have made herself some weird drink because she came out with a glass of purple liquid.
She set the drink down while ringing me up. As she reached over to grab the costume to put it in a bag she knocked it over with the back of her hand spilling it all over my costume. "Whoops," she said convincing no one it was an accident. I grabbed the costume expecting it to be covered but the liquid seemed to have slid off or something? It was completely clean. "Sorry about that!" She said. I eyed her warily but purchased the costume, happy to be away from her.
The party approached and I found myself looking in the mirror waiting for my friends to pic me up. I hated that I had wasted another year in a boring male costume.
Luke, Ryan and Steve showed up in the car as Mario, Toad and Bowser.
The party, despite my disapointement at my costume, was great. There were amazing costumes, good drinks, loud music and a vibe that was off the hook! Sadly my stomach had started to hurt and my muscles ached. I wondered if I had the flu.
"You ok sweetie?" A girl in a vampire costume asked.
"Yeah I am fine!" I said then coughed a little. My voice was hoarse and a little higher than normal. I stood up and looked at her, putting on a smile. "Wanna grab a drink?" She agreed and we moved to the drinks talking and laughing. It was easy conversation, some of the easiest I had had with a girl. Annoyingly my voice felt funnier and funnier but I ignored it. Finally I asked her if she wanted to go dance with me, she looked a little awkward and said she didn't swing that way.
She left me and I felt a massive cramp. I ran to the bathroom and looked at myself in the mirror. My mouth opened into a silent scream. Looking back at me was a chick, she had short hair and manly features but a chick non-the less. That's when I noticed my costume was slowly changing, my overalls were forming a pink dress, my shoes turning into heels. I wanted to rip it off, not understanding what was going on. Before I could another wave of cramps hit me and I bent over in pain. I saw long blonde hair cascade past my face. I felt my chest balloon with two large tits. I felt my waist sinch in and my hips widen. Worst of all I felt my cock shrink and dissapear.
Finally it was over, I looked in the mirror. In front of me was a slutty version of a busty princess peach. My top was a crop top that was pink and showed a large amount of cleavage, my bottom was a pink miniskirt. My makeup was done professionally and I had on jewelry. I had on a fake looking blonde wig over my brunette female hair. "Fuck," I whispered my voice high and meliodic. "It must have been the shop keeper, the potion, that witch!" I exclaimed sounding cute. I resolved to go confront her, but that could wait for tomorrow.
I exited the bathroom and rejoined the party.
"There she is out princess!" My friends in their Mario costumes walked up to me. "Peach my princess it's an honor." Luke as Mario kissed my hand. My other friends did the same. "Luigi is here around her somewhere but, well who cares about Luigi!" I was shocked to hear this, not that they didnt care where I was but that they thought I was still around as Luigi. So reality still thought I was a man, but here I was as a woman.
Some drinks and flirting later I was ready to head home. We had lost Steve to another chick that he was able to take home. But was I actually ready to head home? I was going to track down that witch tomorrow and make her change me back. But for now?
"Hey, wanna take the party to your place? I'm not ready for the party to slow down.
We got back to Luke's place and myself Luke and Ryan continued to drink, flirt and laugh. Finally, I was drunk and ready. I thought about what I was doing but I didn't care. "Hey Mario, Bowser, do you guys want princess peach as much as your characters do?" With that I took off my top and walked into the bedroom that I had seen many times as a man. Luke and Ryan hopped off of their seat tripping over themselves for a wild night.
I left in the morning satisfied and used. I loved being a chick but I couldn't stay like this. Reality still remembered the male version of me. I couldn't be like this forever. I went back to my apartment, found some clothes that fit my form. A baggy t-shirt and basketball shorts. I looked ridiculous. I went back to the costume shop and was relieved that it was open and I could see the damn witch in the window taking some costumes off of a rack.
"Hey, can you fix this?" I motioned to my body as I walked in. She looked at me confused.
"Who are you? Fix what exactly?" She turned and put the costumes in a box.
"You sold me a Luigi costume and it turned me into this!" With that knowledge she slapped her hand to her mouth.
"Why are you still a girl? The potion wears off after 8 hours!" She walked over to me looking intently. "Unless, but no..."
"Unless what?" I asked nervous wondering if there is a way I could be like this forever.
"Unless you let two different people cum inside you multiple times. But that is almost impossible.... Right?" She raised an eyebrow at me. "Right???"
"You see the thing is.... horny nerds can be very motivated by cosplay." I said nervously as she slapped her hand to her forehead.